AI chatbots can point online shoppers toward fake or risky stores, according to a study by intellectual property protection firm Podqi. About 9 percent of 6,795 answers from ChatGPT, Google’s Gemini and Perplexity included a risky website when the chatbots were asked where to buy products.
Risky sites ranged from fake storefronts and suspected counterfeit sellers to inactive or re-registered brand domains.
How the chatbots compared
- Perplexity: risky sites in 15 percent of answers
- ChatGPT: 8 percent
- Gemini: 4 percent
ChatGPT warned users most often, flagging the risk in 24 percent of its answers that included a risky site. Across all three, 57 percent of answers that surfaced a risky site recommended it as a place to buy, 34 percent mentioned it without comment, and only 9 percent warned shoppers away.
Podqi reviewed 4,437 domains and classified 718 as risky, including 351 fake sites and 367 inactive ones.
Regional stores carried the most risk
Questions about international shipping and regional storefronts produced risky sites in 16 percent of answers, the highest of the five question types tested. The chatbots sometimes listed fake regional sites for brands that had none. In one test, Perplexity named the wrong website as Stussy’s official store. Questions about large brands produced risky sites about half as often as questions about smaller brands.
The tests ran in two rounds in September on the logged-out versions of the three services, covering 151 brands including Lululemon, Birkenstock and Le Creuset, using data collected by AI search tracking firm Gauge.
What the companies said
Google said Gemini can make mistakes and that it shows source links so users can check answers. OpenAI said it is improving safeguards to reduce deceptive websites in shopping results. Perplexity said it does not claim perfect accuracy.
Podqi chief executive Trevor West advised shoppers to verify a website before entering personal or payment details, and to start from a brand’s main website when looking for a regional store. The advice applies equally to Pakistani shoppers using AI tools to find international brands, where fake local storefronts are already a common problem.





